This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Most out-of-touch decisions aren’t made by leaders who don’t care.

They’re made by leaders who don’t know what the people closest to the work already see.

As a company grows, information gets filtered. People soften hard truths. Teams interpret decisions differently.

CEO Disease is a real thing… Basically, the higher a leader rises, the harder it is for real, honest feedback to reach them organically. So their view of what’s happening gets obscured while problems grow in their blind spots.

Then, seemingly out of the blue, a key employee resigns, a major revenue target is missed, or a high-priority initiative stalls because employees aren’t on board.

Greg McKeown says this can be attributed to a “signal” problem.

He observes that leaders who win don’t simply send more messages. They find a better way to hear what’s happening, to truly understand what people mean, and act while there’s time to change course.

This is a huge opportunity for HR leaders!

You can help your CEO stay grounded in what’s really happening, cut through the noise, and focus on the priorities that matter most.

But first, you have to understand those priorities. What is your CEO trying to accomplish? What’s getting in the way? And which decisions are they making without a clear picture of what’s happening across the organization?

Once you have that alignment, the tips in this email will help you turn down the noise and turn up the signal.

Keep scrolling to see the playbook for this episode!

👀 Here's what you get in today's edition of the Culture Creators:

  • How HR can help the CEO spot blind spots before they affect retention or execution

  • What an interrogator’s approach to listening can teach HR about helping the CEO spot early signs of business problems

  • How HR can help the CEO test whether recurring work still matters—and free up capacity for higher priorities

Check out the episode wherever you get podcasts.

— Nate Bagley, Producer of Culture Creators

Are You a Culture Leader?

Get insider access to the playbooks, tools, and strategies used by today’s most effective culture leaders delivered right to your inbox.⁠

Greg’s shorthand is simple:

Clarity = signal ÷ noise.

When things feel muddy or unclear, the instinct is often to send more messages, schedule another meeting, or add another survey.

But Greg’s argument is different.

He says clarity can actually improve faster when you remove the noise that clouds your view or distracts you from what matters.

If you know what matters to your CEO, you can look for the employee experiences, patterns, and points of friction that might affect their priority, and take action before a problem becomes a crisis.

Start here: understand your CEO’s priority

Before you build a new dashboard or launch another survey, have a conversation with your CEO. Ask:

  • What are the most important outcomes you’re trying to achieve right now?

  • Where are you least confident about what’s happening on the ground?

  • What decision is coming up that better information could change?

Listen, reflect back what you heard, and check that you’ve got it right. Then choose one priority together and propose a small test.

For example, if the CEO is worried about retaining experienced support staff and maintaining customer coverage, you might say:

❝

“I’d like to spend four weeks understanding what’s making it harder for our support team to do their best work. I’ll look for recurring themes, connect them to coverage and retention, and bring you one recommendation. Can we review what I find together next month?”

The goal is to help your CEO make a better-informed decision while there’s still time to act. That’s how HR can become a trusted partner in solving a business problem.

Here are six ideas from Greg to help you put that approach into practice.

1. Stop trusting your own read. Get proof.

Greg has a quick test for how well people listen.

“If I ask a group of 500 people, put their hand up if they’re above average listener, every hand goes up.”

Everyone laughs. But the serious question is the one that follows: How do you know you understood someone?

Greg’s answer is a four-step method:

  • Listen: Make it safe for the other person to say what they mean.

  • Reflect: Put what you think the person means into words and check whether you’ve understood.

  • Speak: Make your own message clear.

  • Confirm: Ask the other person to explain what they heard in their own words.

This process helps avoid confusion between you and your CEO. AND between you and any employees you speak with.

The strategic logic: A conversation can feel aligned while two people leave with different ideas about the decision. Catching that gap early can save a team from a week of rework—or a quarter spent solving the wrong problem.

Put it to work: Here are examples of how Culture Creator CEOs have sought clarity rather than making strategic (or interpersonal) decisions based on assumptions:

  • Study your outliers before you roll something out. At Southwest, one of three reservation centers kept outperforming the others. Instead of guessing why, Ann’s team studied what that center’s leader actually did. She talked to every employee at the start and end of every shift. Ann Rhoades says her turnover was 6% against an industry average of 25%. They taught the habit to the other managers and, she says, got the same results. Watch Ann on the reservation centers

  • Check that people are doing what you think they’re doing. Early on, Bobby Herrera met every candidate himself and opened each interview by “flipping over the resume” to learn who the person was. As Populus Group grew, he handed hiring to people who had watched him do it, and assumed they were doing the same. They weren’t. He only found out when the wrong hires started showing up as attrition. Watch Bobby on the assumption he got wrong

  • Measure it instead of assuming you know. When Garry Ridge set out to turn WD-40 into a global company, he admitted something most CEOs won’t. He brought in the company’s first employee opinion survey in 2000 “because I didn’t know what the state of our organization was.” The culture wasn’t bad, but it had been built for a U.S.-only company. WD-40 broke the results down by country and department, then handed each leader their own numbers: “This is what you and your people said. You own this.” HR supplied the tools, but as Garry put it, HR “can’t change the results.” Watch Garry on the survey

2. Make it safe to say what people actually mean.

When Satya Nadella took over Microsoft, he did something unexpected and unconventional.

He brought in a book on nonviolent communication, and gave a copy to everyone on the executive team.

Greg says Brad Smith (the President of Microsoft) told him, “This was not what we were expecting.”

You could not imagine Steve Ballmer or Bill Gates doing this. They were famous for yelling things like, "That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard!"

But behavior like that pushes the signal way down.  It makes it unsafe for people to wrestle with their ideas and figure out what actually they think, and what they actually mean.

Nadella followed up the gesture with behavior. Greg says he called new employees for half-hour conversations to ask how they saw the company and what they were understanding. Greg sees that commitment to listening as part of the foundation for Microsoft’s broader renaissance.

The strategic logic: The signal depends on a leader’s ability to get an honest picture of what’s going on in their business. Your people won’t be honest unless they feel safe. If people are taught to hold back because they’re punished for being forthright, leaders will make decisions with an inaccurate picture of what’s happening. That can leave you trying to fix a problem after the people closest to it have seen it coming for a long time.

Put it to work: Here are specific examples of how other leaders from the Culture Creators podcast have intentionally created systems that make employees feel safe to share openly:

  • Make the hard feedback mandatory. At Ethena, Roxanne Petraeus runs “Feedback Fridays” with her direct reports. Each week they have to give her “constructive criticism” and tell her something she could have done better. This allows her to demonstrate how to receive critical feedback, and shows how valuable it is as a growth tool. Making it required gives them cover to say the uncomfortable thing. Watch Roxanne explain Feedback Fridays

  • Rename failure. At WD-40, Garry Ridge stopped talking about mistakes and started calling them “learning moments”: any outcome, good or bad, that gets shared openly so everyone can learn from it. When he asked people to share theirs, they were reluctant… until he celebrated those willing to share. Watch Garry on learning moments

  • Let employees set part of the culture agenda. Every month, Derrick Hall meets with the Arizona Diamondbacks’ employees of the month and a group of VPs. The meeting ends with the employees pitching culture ideas. If an idea won’t work, leaders say so and explain why right there. Watch Derrick on the President’s Council

  • Make trust your top metric. Bobby Herrera, CEO of Populus Group, uses a Speed of Trust survey that asks employees how much they trust him, the executive team, and the company’s decisions. He calls it the single most important metric he measures. Watch Bobby on measuring trust. Watch Bobby discuss the Speed of Trust

3. Notice the breadcrumbs.

Eric Maddox had eight weeks of interrogation training and, Greg says, nearly failed the course.

At first, Maddox followed a script. He questioned prisoners for hours and got nowhere. Then one of them told him: “Look, Eric, you don’t get me. And you don’t want to get me.”

Maddox changed his approach. Instead of relying on threats, he tried to understand the people across from him. They sensed the change and began sharing their stories. As he listened, he started noticing details he would have missed before.

Maddox described the shift as “I erase my world.” His point: put your own assumptions and agenda aside long enough to understand someone else’s. As he put it, “Everyone is constantly feeding you breadcrumbs all the time.”

The lesson for leaders: when people feel threatened or dismissed, they’re less likely to share what they really know. When they feel heard and understood, you create more room for honesty, collaboration, and the information you need to make better decisions.

The strategic logic: A single comment isn’t a trend. But if the same friction keeps coming up, or a team is repeatedly surprised by the same kind of problem, there may be a signal worth following. Treat it as an invitation to understand, not as a diagnosis of an individual.

Put it to work: Think of a recent surprise connected to a priority your CEO cares about: a regretted departure, a missed milestone, or a change that didn’t land. Ask: “What was the earliest sign? Who noticed it? Where did the information stop moving?” Choose one point in that chain to improve.

4. Build a system as good as your intentions.

What happens when employees know their leaders genuinely care about them?

Greg points to Herb Kelleher, co-founder of Southwest Airlines. The airline started with $500,000 in seed money and had a market value of more than $26 billion by the end of 2018.

Kelleher’s care for people helped shape Southwest’s culture—and that culture became a defining part of the company’s success.

But Herb didn’t rely on good intentions to show his care.

Greg says he built a system—a kind of second brain—that helped him keep track of what was happening in employees’ lives, from birthdays and anniversaries to health challenges, so he could respond in a timely way.

That kind of care helped create a culture where people felt connected to the company and to each other. In 1991, as fuel prices climbed, some Southwest employees voluntarily contributed from their paychecks toward the airline’s fuel bill. Their contributions were small compared with the bill, but the gesture said something about how invested they felt.

When Herb died in 2019, more than 5,000 people gathered at a Dallas convention center to celebrate his life. He had built relationships that mattered far beyond the workplace.

The business results mattered, too. In 1993, Southwest’s turnover was 4.5%—less than half the airline industry’s rate. Around the same time, Southwest earned the industry’s Triple Crown for on-time performance, baggage handling, and fewest customer complaints. Plenty of factors shaped those results, but caring for employees was central to the culture Southwest built.

The strategic logic: Retention is one outcome. Discretionary effort is another: when people feel valued, they may be more willing to share ideas, help a teammate, or go the extra mile for a customer. In Nectar’s employee survey, 71% said they’d be less likely to leave if they were recognized more frequently, and 77.9% said they’d be more productive. Those are employees’ own expectations, not proof that recognition alone causes those results. But they show why helping people feel seen belongs in conversations about retention and performance.

A reliable way to notice what people need and respond gives leaders a better chance to build that trust—and address friction before a valued employee walks out the door.

Put it to work: Here are examples of how other leaders from the Culture Creators podcast have shown they care about employees through the systems they build:

  • Plan for life before it happens. At Comma Copywriting, four of the seven people on Crystalee Beck’s leadership team, including her, had babies within six months. At a team retreat she brought out a giant calendar. Everyone listed their responsibilities on sticky notes, and they decided who would cover whom during each leave. Clients got two weeks’ notice and an introduction to the person covering. Crystalee says that was their first million-dollar year. Watch Crystalee on the coverage plan

  • Have a conversation within 24 hours of every resignation. JetBlue requires a manager to talk with anyone who resigns within 24 hours, to understand why and see whether the decision can be reversed. Ann Rhoades says the answers come back the same again and again: “I wasn’t recognized for my performance,” and they didn’t think anyone cared. Watch Ann on the 24-hour rule

  • Fund care and let employees decide where it goes. Lemonade Stand matches part of each employee’s paycheck and gives the money back to the team to spend on “anyone other than yourself,” with one condition: share the story afterward. Employees started using it for colleagues going through hard times. When one team member’s husband was diagnosed with cancer, leadership promised he’d have a job no matter what happened, and his coworkers covered groceries and date nights. Derek Miner says they now have thousands of these stories. Watch Derek on the giving fund

5. Catch people doing good.

Ward Clapham wanted police officers to build stronger relationships with young people in the community.

At the Richmond RCMP detachment, he introduced “positive tickets” for doing something good. The tickets could be exchanged for rewards such as food or activities, but the larger purpose was to create a positive interaction and open the door to a relationship.

In Clapham’s account, the tickets were one of several youth-prevention initiatives associated with a drop in youth-related service calls.

Trevor connected the idea to a customer’s goal of catching people living their core values. The useful workplace question is: What behavior do we want people to see, recognize, and repeat?

The strategic logic: Values can become most visible when someone violates them. Specific recognition gives leaders another way to show what those values look like in practice.

Put it to work: Here are examples of how CEOs from previous Culture Creator episodes reward the behaviors they want to see more of:

  • Make recognition part of leaders’ jobs, not their personalities. Anita told Ann Rhoades that most CEOs she works with struggle to recognize people. Ann’s fix at JetBlue was to put recognition and people metrics into the bonus plan for the CEO and every leader. They also built an app where employees recognize each other’s behaviors. Each recognition goes to the manager, who calls it out at that location’s monthly town hall. Watch Ann on recognition in the bonus plan

  • Tie every shout-out to a value. Crystalee Beck’s team found its values by writing sticky notes about colleagues who already lived “the Comma way” and looking for patterns. Each month, the Right On award goes to someone who lived one of those values, with a shout-out naming which one and a gift card. People see the values in action, recognized, and repeated. Watch Crystalee on the Right On award

  • Show employees on the walls, not just players. When Derrick Hall arrived at the Arizona Diamondbacks, every photo in the office hallways showed something that happened on the field. Now team photos alternate with photos of employees at work and out in the community. It’s a daily reminder that the organization notices what its staff do, not only its athletes. Watch Derrick on the hallway photos

  • Let people who’ve lived the culture choose who gets recognized. For more than 15 years, Bobby Herrera has given an annual Compass Award to the employee who best lived Populus Group’s culture code. Nominations come from former winners and his executive team, and Bobby says he can’t choose the winner himself. Every October, the winners go on a surprise retreat to discuss what the culture should start, stop, and continue. Watch Bobby on the Compass Award

6. Run a reverse pilot.

A new senior vice president at a $60 billion company inherited a recurring report that involved half the organization. He didn’t know whether anyone used it.

Greg says the executive stopped sending it. Two weeks passed. Then four. Then eight. No one had asked for it. Greg describes the result as a “50% rebate” for the executive and his team.

That’s a reverse pilot: temporarily stop doing something and see what happens.

The strategic logic: Organizations collect work the same way they collect old clothes: the moment you consider getting rid of something, you remember one time it was useful. A bounded pause tests whether the work still earns its cost without turning the decision into a debate about whether it might be useful someday.

Put it to work: Look for one recurring activity that may be consuming time better spent on a priority your CEO has identified. Estimate the hours it takes, set a clear pause period, and agree on what would trigger restarting it. Check in at two, four, and eight weeks. Keep the test to non-critical work; don’t pause something tied to safety, compliance, or a customer commitment.

The “so what?”

Start by understanding what your CEO is trying to accomplish—and where they need a clearer view.

Then align your listening around one of those priorities. Find an early signal, understand the people and context behind it, and bring back a recommendation while there’s still time to act. Follow up on what happened, and tell employees how their input was used.

Over time, that’s how HR can build a stronger relationship with the CEO: by helping leadership see what it might otherwise miss and make better decisions about the goals that matter most.

SHRM is a member-driven catalyst for creating better workplaces where people and businesses thrive together. As the trusted authority on all things work, SHRM is the foremost expert, researcher, advocate, and thought leader on issues and innovations impacting today's evolving workplaces. With nearly 340,000 members in 180 countries, SHRM touches the lives of more than 362 million workers and their families globally. Discover more at SHRM.org.

We turned Ann’s operating system into a Toolkit for YOU! SHRM members can access the toolkit here:

Southwest and JetBlue’s cultures aren’t seen as “nice to have” or “cute, not crucial.” They are a key ingredient of the business strategy, because they have a direct impact on how well the strategy is executed.

Nectar helps leaders like you create a culture system that drives performance, so values become visible, caring becomes the default, employees feel more accountable, and leaders can see what is actually happening across the employee experience.

Check out AANA’s story to see how we can help a company like yours:

See Nectar in action:

❝

“I think that in general, there’s more good will to act than there is good information to inform the action.”

Greg McKeown

Plenty of managers would do the right thing for their people if they knew what the right thing was.

They just need to be shown what’s possible, and given permission to act. (Better yet, make their actions part of a system that reinforces the behaviors your value most!)